top of page
Oh How Sweet!
We love saying that we get something new in the shop every day…and since we always buy in small quantities, what we have is always fresh and delicious. Here’s a little peek at the sweets we currently have at The Sweet Shop NYC:
Ice Cream, You Scream:
Small batch from The Sweet Shop NYC Creamery Co., Il Laboratorio Del Gelato and The Lemon Ice King of Corona.
Cup of Pie:
Delicious Pie gets scooped into a cup, served warm and topped with Ice Cream! Apple, Pecan, Triple Berry and Cherry.
Ice Cream Sundaes:
Our Signature Sundaes are topped with the Best Hot Fudge and our Housemade Whipped Cream.
The Jars:
Wall to wall candy. Over 100 jars of sweet, sour, chewy, crunchy, yummy candy. You pick it, we’ll mix it and can even top your Ice Cream with any candy in the shop!
Chocolate Bars:
We always have new chocolate bars to try! Right now the Dubai Chocolate Bar is still at the top of the list though.
Sour City:
How SOUR do you like it? Try Sour Death if you dare! Or how about Sour Belts, Warheads, Toxic Waste, Sour Cola or Sour Pigs!
The Mini Bar:
Milk or Dark? Handmade Marshmallow. From the Mother Fluffer to the S’more to Love, you’re going to love these handmade delicious two bite chocolate covered bars.
Licorice Lane:
A great selection of Red and Black licorice options from around the world including salted, half salt, sweet, chewy, hard and filled.
Old Time Favorites:
Candy Necklaces, Pez, Pop Rocks, Tootsie Rolls, Charleston Chews and lots more.
Swedish Candy:
We’ve had Swedish Candy since before it became a trend! Both Sweet and Sour, can you say BUBS and Sour Skulls please?
Freeze Dried Treats:
he classic Astronaut ice cream and other candy goes from from soft & chewy to crunchy.
Lotsa Lollies:
We have a great lollipop selection: Whirly Pops, Tootsie Pops, Smarties, Chupa Chups, Melody Pops and more!
Ice Cream Sandwiches:
Choose any two cookies and your favorite scoop and we’ll make you something delicious!
The Cookie Jar:
Big Cookies, Black and Whites, Stuffed Cookies, Biscotti, and lots of different Chocolate Chip choices!
Chocolate: We love Chocolate!
Nonpareils, Peanut Butter Cups, Gophers, Pretzels, Peanuts, Gummy Bears, Marzipan and more!
bottom of page