Oh How Sweet!

We love saying that we get something new in the shop every day…and since we always buy in small quantities, what we have is always fresh and delicious. Here’s a little peek at the sweets we currently have at The Sweet Shop NYC:

The Jars:

A dazzling assortment of over 60 different candies.

Artisanal Bars:

Handcrafted by:

Mast, Raaka, Pump Street, The Chocolate Conspiracy, just to name a few.

Sour City:

Sour Patch Kids, Warheads, Sour Belts, Toxic Waste and more.

Old Time Favorites: Candy Necklaces, Pop Rocks, Chuckles, Charlston Chews and lots more.

Butter Crunch:

Our World’s Best Butter Crunch is available in Dark, Milk and White Chocolate with Almonds. Hurry!

Licorice Lane:

Over 40 types of licorice including salted, half salts, sweet, chewy, hard and filled.

Old Time Favorites:

Candy Necklaces, Pop Rocks, Chuckles, Charlston Chews and lots more.

Gummy Town:

Fried Eggs, Army Men, Chicken Feet, Pigs, sours and of course Bears!

Handmade Marshmallows:

Covered in either milk or dark chocolate and stuffed with caramel, tart raspberry jam or grahams.

Chewing Gum: 

Chiclets, Big League, Black Jack Gum, Bubblicious, Hubba Bubba, Bazooka, Razzles.

Lotsa Lollies: 

We have a great selection of lollipops to choose from.

Fresh Baked Cookies: 

Baked daily in the shop with artisanal dough from SweetDough handmade in small batches in Brooklyn.

Handcrafted Chocolates :

Made especially for The Sweet Shop NYC and are available by the piece, pound or package.

We've Got A Lot of Gluten-Free:

Our candy selections vary, check out our current options.


Gilda’s Biscotti, Dallas Caramels, Jacobson's Salt Caramels, The Crispery Rice Crispycakes, Coops Hot Fudge and Caramel Sauces.

We're Nuts About Nut-Free:

All of our nut free candy comes from Certified nut free facilities.

Ice Cream, You Scream:

From Odd Fellows Ice Cream Co. both delicious seasonal flavors and  2 vegan options daily, Il Laboratorio del Gelato, Melt Bakery Ice Cream Sandwiches, Too Cool Chix Ice Cream Sandwiches and our own Shaved Ice Snowballs!

Order Online